Does the judge always agree with the prosecutor?
Asked by: Shyanne Nolan | Last update: October 19, 2025Score: 5/5 (39 votes)
In some jurisdictions, if the prosecution and the defendant agree to a sentence and the judge accepts the negotiated plea, that judge must accept the entire agreement, including the agreed-upon sentence. Other states don't require the judge to accept the sentencing recommendation even when accepting a plea agreement.
Can the judge overrule the prosecutor?
Judges do not have control over which charges are brought against a defendant but may have discretion in sentencing, even when a plea bargain is involved. Thus, a judge can accept a plea bargain while simultaneously imposing a different sentence than the sentence to which the defendant and the prosecutor agreed.
Who has more power, a judge or a prosecutor?
the prosecutor has the most power over your case and your legal future. They have discretion to drop or amend charges, and to some extent over your plea. They would also be the ones able to bring new charges against you.
Do judges usually accept plea deals?
However, you should know that even if you and the prosecutor reach an agreement that you are favorable of, judges have the authority to reject plea agreements, and sometimes do. If a judge rejects a plea, the agreement you and the prosecutor have made becomes null and void.
Can a judge disagree with prosecutor?
Even if a judge does not agree with the prosecutor's decision to charge someone with a particular crime, the judge is powerless to undo the prosecutor's action.
ASAP Rocky's Lawyer Challenged The Prosecutor To A Fight? Explosive Accusations On Day 2 Of Trial
How much power do prosecutors have?
For someone arrested for a criminal offense, prosecutors are arguably the most powerful figures in the legal system. Prosecutors decide what, if anything, to charge—a decision that can be life-altering before and after a conviction.
Can a prosecutor appeal a dismissal?
DOUBLE JEOPARDY AND GOVERNMENT APPEALS OF CRIMINAL DISMISSALS. DISCUSSION OF THE ISSUES RAISED BY THE CRIMINAL APPEALS ACT OF 1971 WHICH ALLOWS THE PROSECUTION TO APPEAL A TRIAL COURT'S DISMISSAL OF AN INFORMATION OR INDICTMENT.
Do prosecutors like plea bargains?
The fact is, plea agreements are often offered by prosecutors because the evidence against you is weak, and therefore they cannot develop a strong case against you. Prosecutors do not want to lose at trial, and are not your advocates or friends.
Can a judge lower a charge?
That being said, a judge does have the ability to reduce certain felonies to misdemeanors. An experienced criminal defense attorney will seek to convince a judge to grant judicial diversion on a qualifying misdemeanor offense, whereby a defendant is given the opportunity to earn a dismissal.
Who decides whether a plea bargain will be offered?
Judge's approval: In California, as in most states, the plea bargain needs to be approved by a judge. During the plea hearing, the judge will confirm that the defendant understands the rights they are waiving by pleading guilty, such as the right to a jury trial, and that the plea is voluntary.
What not to say to a prosecutor?
- Agreeing to a deal you don't understand: Sometimes, a prosecutor may try to negotiate your charges with you. ...
- Giving them information they don't know: Much like police, prosecutors may also try to act like your friend when speaking with them.
Can prosecutors make arrests?
(a) While the decision to arrest is often the responsibility of law enforcement personnel, the decision to institute formal criminal proceedings is the responsibility of the prosecutor.
Is a prosecutor more powerful than a lawyer?
While defense attorneys are obligated to vigorously defend their clients whether guilty or not, prosecutors exercise the sovereign power of the state by representing the best interests of the community, which not only includes prosecuting crimes but also honoring the rights of the accused.
What happens if you reject a plea deal?
Suppose a plea deal is rejected, and the case proceeds to trial. In that case, the defendant will have the opportunity to present their case, challenge the prosecution's evidence, and have their guilt or innocence determined by the judge or jury.
Who can override a judge's decision?
The court of appeals may review the factual findings made by the trial court or agency, but generally may overturn a decision on factual grounds only if the findings were “clearly erroneous.”
How do you know if your case will be dismissed?
Some signs we look for are a lack of physical evidence, gaps in the chain of custody of evidence, contradictory eyewitness accounts, or witnesses who lack credibility. If the prosecution's case is built on a shaky foundation, they often realize a dismissal or plea deal is their best option.
Can a judge drop charges UK?
Without concrete evidence to support the charges, the judge or CPS may opt to drop the case. We can assess the evidence gathered by the prosecution and advise you of whether or not we believe charges are likely to be dropped.
What is the lowest charge in court?
There are 3 types of criminal charges, infractions, misdemeanors, and felonies. Infractions: Infractions are the least serious type of crime. Infractions, like speeding tickets, are usually handled in traffic court. Someone convicted only of an infraction cannot be punished with jail time.
How do you ask a judge to dismiss a charge?
A defense attorney could file a motion – a request for the judge to decide an issue – before, during, or after a trial. If the judge agrees, it might lead to a charge's dismissal by the judge or make the prosecutor's ability to carry their burden of proof so limited the charges may be withdrawn.
Can you negotiate with the prosecutor?
A plea agreement is a negotiated guilty plea in a criminal case. The prosecutor and defense attorney can negotiate a plea deal, but it is up to the defendant to accept or reject the deal. A plea deal can get a lower sentence, fewer charges, or a lesser charge.
How to tell if a prosecutor's case is weak?
Some of the most common signs of a weak criminal case include a lack of sufficient evidence, an unlawful arrest, a lack of credible witnesses, mistakes in the criminal complaint, and a defendant having valid legal arguments. Suppose one or more of these common issues exist in a prosecutor's case against you.
Do prosecutors argue in court?
Prosecutors are prohibited from making arguments that calls for the jury to "send a message" with their verdict. They are also prohibited from suggesting to the jury that their guilty verdict is necessary in order to ensure that the community is safe.
What is one reason prosecutors may decide to dismiss cases?
Legal Issues or Procedural Errors: Prosecutors may dismiss a case if there are significant legal issues or procedural errors that could compromise the fairness of the trial. This could include violations of the defendant's constitutional rights, mishandling of evidence, or other legal irregularities.
How do you know if a case is being built against you?
If if the state you refer to is in the US, you could try calling the local public defender's office for the county where the charges would likely be filed and see if they could run your name and find out if there's a case and/or a warrant out on you.