Is a defense attorney obligated to turn over evidence?

Asked by: Terrell Grady  |  Last update: August 26, 2022
Score: 4.8/5 (54 votes)

It appears clear that, where the item is contraband an instrumentality or fruit of a crime, the criminal defense attorney has an affirmative responsibility to turn-over the item to law enforcement agents, irrespective of the existence of a court order or a written request.

Does the defense need to turn over evidence?

Under California law, the defense is required to turn over specific information to the prosecution. In criminal cases, the prosecution has an obligation under the constitution to turn over what is known as Brady material.

Does defense have to share discovery?

While the prosecutor has a legal obligation to share material exculpatory evidence with the defense, attorney work product is rarely released. Other evidence may be disclosable, but only if the defense lawyer makes a discovery request for it during the pretrial stage.

Does the defense have to disclose exculpatory evidence?

The Brady Rule, named after Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963), requires prosecutors to disclose materially exculpatory evidence in the government's possession to the defense.

How can a defense attorney discredit evidence?

So, again, the way to discredit a witness is to bring up prior inconsistent statements that they made. The way to discredit a witness is to call other witness or cross-examine other witnesses and bring up key points about your main witness's testimony and impeach them through over witness statements.

Defense Attorney Says Prosecution Must Turn Over Unedited Evidence Without Redactions

25 related questions found

How do you destroy credibility?

  1. Show contradictions between their pre-trial testimony and trial testimony.
  2. Exposing their 'little white lie'
  3. Showing a witness didn't know the answer during deposition but suddenly at trial they know all the answers.

Can a case go to trial without evidence?

This most often occurs in domestic violence cases, but it can occur in any case where a complainant is able to identify the suspect. There may be no forensic evidence, no camera footage, no witnesses or anything else that supports what the complainant has said.

What type of evidence must always be turned over by the prosecutor?

What types of evidence must always be turned over by the prosecutor to the defense in virtually all jurisdictions? Exculpatory evidence is any evidence that may be favorable to the defendant.

What is a Brady motion?

A Brady motion is filed to compel the prosecution to turn over any favorable exculpatory evidence. In other words, a Brady motion is a defendant's request that the prosecution in a California criminal case hand over any potentially “exculpatory” evidence that might be favorable to the defense.

Does evidence have to be shared?

When does evidence have to be disclosed? Federal courts have held that the law requires the disclosure of all exculpatory evidence regardless of whether the defendant requests it. The US Attorney will disclose exculpatory evidence almost immediately during the discovery process.

What kind of evidence tends to prove a defendant's innocence?

Exculpatory evidence is evidence favorable to the defendant in a criminal trial that exonerates or tends to exonerate the defendant of guilt.

What is a Brady violation when it comes to discovery issues?

A “Brady Violation” is what happens when the prosecutors in a criminal case fail to perform their constitutional duty to turn over helpful evidence to the people they have charged with crimes. Everyone has the right to due process and a fair trial.

What is the Giglio rule?

In the 1963 Brady v. Maryland case, the Supreme Court held that prosecutors must disclose any exculpatory evidence to the accused material to his guilt or punishment. Subsequently, in the 1972 Giglio v.

Does the defendant have to give evidence at trial?

Should the defendant give evidence? Defendants in any criminal trial will have to decide whether to give evidence themselves. As a defendant you are entitled to remain silent at trial and leave it to the prosecution to prove its case.

What does preponderance of evidence mean?

Preponderance of the evidence is one type of evidentiary standard used in a burden of proof analysis. Under the preponderance standard, the burden of proof is met when the party with the burden convinces the fact finder that there is a greater than 50% chance that the claim is true.

What is the remedy for a Brady violation?

Ordinarily the remedy for a Brady violation is the reversal of the conviction because the suppressed exculpatory evidence was “material.” After looking at the record, an appellate court would decide that the suppressed evidence created a reasonable probability of a different outcome such that confidence in the ...

What is omission guilt?

Guilt By Omission: When Prosecutors Withhold Evidence Of Innocence Prosecutors are obliged to turn over evidence that could exonerate a defendant. But if that evidence never makes it to trial, for whatever reason, quite often nobody will ever know.

What is a brandy motion?

A Brady violation is a situation where the prosecution holds back information or evidence that could have helped you defend against the charges in your case. You can file a Brady motion to ask the judge to dismiss the case if this happens.

What is considered exculpatory evidence?

Evidence, such as a statement, tending to excuse, justify, or absolve the alleged fault or guilt of a defendant. See also Brady Rule.

Why is it called a Brady violation?

The term comes from the 1963 U.S. Supreme Court case Brady v. Maryland, in which the Supreme Court ruled that suppression by the prosecution of evidence favorable to a defendant who has requested it violates due process.

Why is circumstantial evidence important?

In practice, circumstantial evidence can have an advantage over direct evidence in that it can come from multiple sources that check and reinforce each other. Eyewitness testimony can be inaccurate at times, and many persons have been convicted on the basis of perjured or otherwise mistaken testimony.

What are the ethical obligations of a prosecutor?

The prosecutor should seek to protect the innocent and convict the guilty, consider the interests of victims and witnesses, and respect the constitutional and legal rights of all persons, including suspects and defendants.

What happens when there is not enough evidence?

Evidence which fails to meet the burden of proof. In a trial, if the prosecution finishes presenting their case and the judge finds they have not met their burden of proof, the judge may dismiss the case (even before the defense presents their side) for insufficient evidence.

How can I be prosecuted when there is no evidence?

The simple answer is, “no.” You cannot be convicted of a crime without evidence. You cannot be convicted of a state crime. You cannot be convicted of a federal crime. If there is no evidence against you, under the law, it simply is not possible for the prosecutor's office to obtain a conviction at trial.

What is the strongest type of evidence?

Direct Evidence

The most powerful type of evidence, direct evidence requires no inference and directly proves the fact you are investigating. The evidence alone is the proof, if you believe the accounts.