Who goes first in cross-examination?

Asked by: Rodrick Rutherford  |  Last update: June 15, 2025
Score: 4.1/5 (74 votes)

Generally, a witness is initially questioned by the party who called them to the stand on direct examination . Afterwards, the opposing party can question the witness on cross-examination, often using targeted or leading questions (note that leading questions are not allowed during direct examination).

Who is cross-examined first?

Witnesses shall be first examined-in-chief, then (if the adverse party so desires) cross-examined, then (if the party calling him so desires) re-examined.

What is the correct order of witness examinations?

Direct examination of witnesses

If you have more than one witness, you will need to choose the order they will testify. As a general rule, if you are testifying, you should testify either first to set up the overall story of the case, or last, to summarize the case and drive home the important points.

What is the first rule of cross-examination?

The first rule of cross-examination is that there are no absolute rules of cross-examination. There are merely guidelines and suggestions. Every cross-examination is different, and has to be approached with flexibility.

What is the golden rule of cross-examination?

Preparation is the golden rule of cross-examination. The most effective cross is not random or casual but strategically planned to support your theory of the case. The first step is to prepare a theory of your case. The questions you ask on cross-examination should be consistent with your theory.

Murdaugh Murder Trial: FULL cross examination of Alex Murdaugh

20 related questions found

What not to say during cross-examination?

Other 'don'ts' are not to insist on yes or no answers; not to create the opportunity for ruinous redirect examination; not to argue; not to object to the judge's questions; not to say, 'Remember you are under oath;' and not to be baited by the opposing attorney.

How do you start a cross-examination?

How to do a Cross Examination
  1. Analyzing the witness' statement and ranking the possible issues in order of importance. ...
  2. Put the strongest points first and last and the weaker point in the middle.
  3. Develop a series of questions under each of the points.
  4. Use introductory remarks and transitions between each point.

What are 3 rules for composing cross-examination questions?

The Top 3 Rules of Cross-Examination
  • Leading Questions Only. The Federal Rules of Evidence and the rules of evidence of all states permit leading questions on cross (Fed. ...
  • One New Fact Per Question. ...
  • Break Cross Into a Series of Logical Progressions to Each Specific Factual Goal.

How long is a typical cross-examination?

The overwhelming majority of witnesses can be cross-examined in 30 minutes or less even in very complicated cases. Effective cross-examination makes a point quickly and keeps the jury engaged from the moment you ask your first question until you pass the witness for re-direct.

What comes first direct or cross-examination?

“Lawyers do not use examination and cross-examination to make people 'look bad. '” What is cross-examination? After each witness has been questioned during direct examination, the lawyer for each side has the chance to question the other side's witnesses.

Which witness goes first?

The side bringing the case is the side that bears the burden of proof, and thus always goes first. This is the prosecuting attorney in a criminal case, or the plaintiff in a civil case. The defense then follows with their opening statement.

What are leading questions in cross-examination?

Each question you ask during your cross-examination should be a leading question, such as “It was raining that evening, correct?” Leading questions nudge witnesses in the direction you want them to go while also limiting their ability to explain their answers. Each question you ask should focus on one fact.

How to cross-examine a liar?

During the cross-examination:

Consider whether the witness is lying, biased, or mistaken, and develop your cross-examination questions and strategy from that standpoint. Obtain concessions that the witness would have to concede or lose credibility by denying.

What is the order of examination?

If you don't pay what the judge said you owe, the other side can ask for a debtor's examination to learn what you own and where you work. They can ask the same about your spouse or registered domestic partner.

How many times can a witness be cross-examined?

If the witness's direct is not long, most judges will only allow a single cross examination (followed by a very brief redirect).

How to answer cross-examination questions in family court?

The Most Important Rule When Being Cross Examined

But cross-examination is not the time to share your perspective or persuade a Family Court judge that you are right! The best method for answering questions during cross-examination is to focus only on the question asked and use as few words as possible to answer.

What is the number one rule of cross-examination?

Use Only Leading Questions

On cross-examination the law permits questions that suggest the answer and allows the attorney to put his words in the witnesses' mouth.

What is not allowed in cross-examination?

However, the attorney conducting the cross-examination may not ask questions outside of scope of the direct examination. In other words, the attorney may not raise issues that go beyond the subject matter of the witness's initial testimony.

What comes after cross-examination?

Code § 772. Current through the 2023 Legislative Session. Section 772 - Phases of examination (a) The examination of a witness shall proceed in the following phases: direct examination, cross-examination, redirect examination, recross-examination, and continuing thereafter by redirect and recross-examination.

What questions should you avoid in cross-examination?

Never ask open-ended questions. Ask only questions you already know the answer to, because you have deposed the witness. Never ask that “one questions too many.” Know which form of cross-examination to use — constructive or destructive — and when.

How should I start a cross-examination?

It is always easier to cross-examine a witness in a chronological progression from general to specific. That is, start with the general questions and progress to specific questions. This structure makes it easier for the jurors to understand the theme and story of your case.

What does hearsay mean in court?

Hearsay is an out-of-court statement offered to prove the truth of whatever it asserts, which is then offered in evidence to prove the truth of the matter. The problem with hearsay is that when the person being quoted is not present, it becomes impossible to establish credibility.

Is cross-examination first?

It is preceded by direct examination (known as examination-in-chief in Ireland, the United Kingdom, Australia, Canada, South Africa, India and Pakistan) and may be followed by a redirect (known as re-examination in the aforementioned countries).

Can you admit evidence on cross-examination?

(5) If the witness denies or does not remember making the statement, and if the statement is on a material issue, then the cross-examiner may introduce extrinsic evidence of it (a written statement, a deposition, or a person claiming to have heard an oral statement).

Can a witness be called twice?

In the United States, a prosecutor can call a witness or witnesses as many times as the prosecutor deems necessary as long as the prosecutor, if challenged, can show good cause for calling the witness/witnesses again.