Why challenge a will?

Asked by: Dr. Trenton Ankunding  |  Last update: May 25, 2026
Score: 4.2/5 (62 votes)

People contest wills due to beliefs the will is invalid or unfair, citing reasons like the testator's lack of mental capacity, undue influence, fraud, or improper execution (e.g., missing signatures, wrong witnesses), with beneficiaries challenging unequal distributions, family rivalry, or feeling cheated, aiming to invalidate the will or change its terms in probate court.

Why would someone challenge a will?

The most common grounds for contesting a will are lack of testamentary capacity, meaning the testator didn't understand the will, and undue influence, where someone coerced the testator. Claims of fraud or improper execution of the will are also frequently cited.

How often do people win contesting a will?

The success rate for contesting a will is generally low (often cited around 1-3% for trials), as courts favor upholding a testator's wishes, but many cases settle, especially in family provision claims where rates can be much higher (e.g., 74% in one Australian study) through mediation, not court. Success hinges on strong evidence of grounds like lack of capacity, undue influence, or forgery, with poor strategy and lack of proof being common reasons for failure, according to sources like Suzanne R. Fanning PLLC and Solomon Hollett Lawyers.
 

Why do people fight over wills?

There are many reasons why families fight over inheritance when a loved one passes away, including: Unequal distributions, or perceived unfairness. Miscommunications about your final wishes. Old-fashioned sibling rivalry.

Who is most likely to contest a will?

Actually, a more common type of Will contest is the beneficiaries of the estate contesting who will run the estate (the executor or trustee) or contending that the person running the estate is doing their job poorly or unlawfully.

Challenging A Will & Inheritance Act Claim Solicitors

39 related questions found

How long does a contested will take to settle?

You can expect them to be less likely to settle—and thus, for the case to extend longer than a year, possibly two years—if there is more money or assets at stake, and the parties are less likely to want to resolve the issues before a trial.

What are the biggest mistakes people make with their will?

“The biggest mistake people make with doing their will or estate plan is simply not doing anything and having no documents at all. For those people who have documents, the next biggest mistake people make is to let the documents get stale.

What are the six worst assets to inherit?

The 6 worst assets to inherit often involve high costs, legal complexities, or emotional burdens, including timeshares, debt-laden properties, family businesses without a plan, collectibles, firearms (due to varying laws), and traditional IRAs for non-spouses (due to the 10-year payout rule), which can become financial or logistical nightmares instead of windfalls. These assets create stress and unexpected expenses, often outweighing their perceived value. 

How to deal with greedy family members after a death?

Tips on How to Deal with Greedy Family Members After Death

  1. Approach All Situations with Empathy. ...
  2. Take Time Apart. ...
  3. Communicate and Listen. ...
  4. Take Care of Yourself. ...
  5. Bring in an Unbiased Party.

What is the 7 year rule for inheritance?

The "7-year inheritance rule" (primarily a UK concept) means gifts you give away become exempt from Inheritance Tax (IHT) if you live for seven years or more after making the gift; if you die within that time, the gift may be taxed, often with a reduced rate (taper relief) applied if you die between years 3 and 7, but at the full 40% if you die within 3 years, helping people reduce their estate's taxable value by giving assets away earlier.
 

What is the 2 year rule after death?

Tax-free lump sum payments (where the individual dies under 75) must be made within two years of the scheme administrator being notified of the death of the individual. Any lump sum payments made after the two-year period will be taxed at the recipient's marginal rate of income tax.

Is contesting a will hard?

A will contest can be a complicated legal process — one that requires more than just frustration or suspicion with how an estate is being divided. And without the right legal representation, even genuine concerns about the validity of a will can be difficult to prove.

How common is it for families to fight over inheritance?

You'd be surprised, 35% of families end up fighting over inheritance. It's hard to think about, but it happens more often than we realize. The truth is, most family conflicts can be avoided with a clear estate plan. It's not just about money, it's about protecting relationships and peace of mind.

How to deal with siblings fighting over inheritance?

Siblings (and parents, while they are still alive) should engage in open and honest conversations about intentions and expectations around inheritance. More to the point, these conversations should take place on an ongoing basis so that everyone remains on the same page even as situations change.

What to do when someone is contesting a will?

Common grounds for challenging a will include undue influence, fraud, improper execution, and disinheritance. If your loved one's estate is facing a will contest, consult an estate planning attorney, gather relevant documents, and understand the contest timeline.

What makes a will uncontestable?

Include a No Contest Clause in the Will

Another strategy to avoid a Will contest includes a “no-contest” or “in terrorem” clause in your Will. A typical “no-contest” clause states that if an heir challenges your Will and loses, then he or she gets nothing.

What is the 40 day rule after death?

The "40-day rule after death" refers to traditions in many cultures and religions (especially Eastern Orthodox Christianity) where a mourning period of 40 days signifies the soul's journey, transformation, or waiting period before final judgment, often marked by prayers, special services, and specific mourning attire like black clothing, while other faiths, like Islam, view such commemorations as cultural innovations rather than religious requirements. These practices offer comfort, a structured way to grieve, and a sense of spiritual support for the deceased's soul.
 

How to deal with two faced family members?

Dealing with two-faced behavior is something everyone encounters at some point. By building boundaries, seeking support, staying grounded, checking facts, practicing self-care, communicating clearly, and detaching with love, you can navigate such situations more effectively.

What are the 3 C's of death?

The "3 Cs of Death" refer to different frameworks for coping with grief, most commonly Choose, Connect, Communicate for general support, or Cause, Catch, Care for helping children understand loss, focusing on agency, social support, and expressing needs, rather than specific clinical stages. Another variation for addiction focuses on the inability to Control, Cause, or Cure another's substance use.
 

Is $500,000 a big inheritance?

Yes, $500,000 is a very significant inheritance for most people, considered a life-changing windfall that provides substantial financial security, freedom, and opportunity, even though it's not enough to fully retire on its own for most individuals. While the average inheritance is much lower, this amount can fund major goals like buying a home, starting a business, or generating significant investment income, making it crucial to manage wisely with professional advice to secure long-term financial well-being. 

How do you make assets untouchable?

Want to make your assets virtually untouchable by creditors and lawsuits? Equity stripping may be the answer. This advanced technique involves encumbering your assets with liens or mortgages held by friendly creditors, such as an LLC or trust you control.

What is the 3-year rule for a deceased estate?

The "deceased estate 3-year rule," or Internal Revenue Code Section 2035, generally requires that certain gifts or transfers made within three years of a person's death are "brought back" and included in their taxable estate for federal estate tax purposes, especially life insurance policies or assets that would have been included in the estate if kept, preventing "deathbed" estate tax avoidance. It also mandates that any gift tax paid on these transfers within the three years is added back to the estate, though outright gifts (not tied to certain "string provisions") are usually excluded from the gross estate, but the gift tax paid is included. 

What is better than making a will?

A living trust might be better if:

You want to avoid the probate process. You want your beneficiaries to have access to funds, property, or other assets while you're still alive.

What is the best way to leave your house to your children?

The best way to leave a house to children usually involves a Revocable Living Trust for probate avoidance and control, or a Will for simplicity (though it goes through probate), with a Transfer-on-Death Deed (TODD) being a simpler, state-dependent alternative to avoid probate. Trusts offer tax efficiency (step-up in basis) and privacy, while TODDs pass the house directly to the beneficiary without probate, ideal if the heir lives there. Consulting an attorney is crucial due to state laws and complex tax implications, especially regarding capital gains. 

Do you pay taxes on money you inherit?

Generally, receiving an inheritance (cash, property, investments) isn't taxable income for the recipient at the federal level in the U.S., but you pay taxes on any income the inheritance generates after you receive it (like interest or dividends), and some states have their own estate or inheritance taxes. The biggest exception is inheriting pre-tax retirement accounts (like traditional IRAs or 401(k)s), where distributions are taxed as ordinary income for the beneficiary.