Can a judge reject a plea at sentencing?

Asked by: Prof. Mafalda Feeney  |  Last update: April 12, 2025
Score: 4.1/5 (48 votes)

Even if the criminal defense attorney and prosecutor agree on a plea agreement, the judge does not have to accept the “plea bargain.”

Can a judge decline a plea deal?

Can the Judge Reject a Plea Agreement? Yes, the judge has a choice of whether to accept or reject a plea agreement. To make that decision, the judge evaluates whether the punishment is appropriate in light of the seriousness of the charges, the defendant's character, and the defendant's prior criminal record.

Can a guilty plea be denied?

If the defendant did not have legal counsel when they made the plea, a judge may look more favorably on their request. A judge must set aside a guilty plea if the circumstances suggest that the defendant is innocent or did not understand the consequences of the guilty plea.

What are three reasons a defendant may choose to accept a plea bargain?

Often, a plea bargain involves reducing a felony to a misdemeanor. This can be especially useful because it may allow the defendant to preserve their civil rights, retain a professional license, and protect their job prospects.

Can plea bargains be overturned?

If you enter into a plea, but later violate a term of the agreement, then the judge has the authority to reverse the bargain.

What Happens if the Judge REJECTS a Plea Deal In a Criminal Case?

37 related questions found

How do you reverse a plea deal?

The defendant brings a motion to withdraw a plea: When a defendant or their legal representative believes the original plea deal contained errors or constitutional violations, they can appeal to a higher court to have the agreement overturned.

How long do I have to accept a plea bargain?

Most plea offers come with an established expiration date, typically set within a few months of the offer's issuance. Once the original plea offer expires, the prosecutor can choose to either extend the same offer or present a new plea deal with potentially less favorable terms.

Does pleading guilty reduce your sentence?

You may be able to enter into a favorable plea agreement with the prosecutor if you agree to plead guilty. They may drop the charges to a less serious offense or agree to reduce your sentence. This can be extremely beneficial, especially if you face a jail or prison sentence.

What happens if you don't accept a plea deal?

This means that the defendant must plead guilty to the crime as agreed upon in the plea bargain and accept the sentence that has been negotiated. If the defendant does not follow through with the terms of the plea bargain, the judge may choose to revoke the plea bargain and the case may proceed to trial.

What factors are considered when a prosecutor considers to offer a plea bargain?

Criminal cases are unique, and many factors can be at play, including the seriousness of the charges, the strength of the evidence, the prosecutor's policies, and the defendant's criminal history.

Why should you never take a plea bargain?

Critics argue that plea bargains can result in innocent people pleading guilty to avoid the risk of a harsher sentence at trial. There are also concerns about the consistency and fairness of plea deals, as well as the potential for prosecutorial overreach.

Can a case be dismissed after pleading guilty?

Except in the case of expungements, the dismissal of charges against a defendant after sentencing is rare and is accomplished only after withdrawal of a plea or taking a conviction to a court other than the trial court and obtaining a reversal of the conviction.

Does pleading not guilty increase your sentence?

By maintaining a not guilty plea, you retain the leverage needed to negotiate a more favorable plea agreement. This could result in lesser charges, reduced sentences, or alternative sentencing options that might not be available if you initially plead guilty.

Does the victim have to agree to a plea deal?

Not only do victims have the right to offer written input into whether a plea bargaining agreement is proper, but also prosecutors must make a reasonable effort to provide them the opportunity to comment on the agreement terms.

Can a judge change a charge?

If the judge thinks a charge was not made out, or another charge unexpectedly was during the course of the trial, he can bring that to the prosecutor's attention and ask for the change. But the decision is up to the prosecutor.

Who controls the plea bargaining process?

A general felony Deputy District Attorney negotiates the plea bargain.

Why would a judge reject a plea deal?

Yes, judges can reject a plea deal if they find it too lenient or too harsh.

What happens if a defendant refuses to enter a plea?

If the defendant refuses to plead, or if a defendant corporation fails to appear, the court must enter a plea of not guilty. Fed.

Why you should never plead guilty?

The consequences of conviction can be costly. You potentially face jail/prison time, fines, court costs, loss of gun rights, loss of voting rights, being kicked out of your apartment, the loss of your job and many other potential "hidden" costs.

How to get a sentence reduced?

You can negotiate for lower criminal penalties during a plea negotiation. Your attorney can argue for a reduced sentence during the sentencing hearing. After conviction, you can file a motion to reconsider your sentence or get an early release with good behavior.

Is it better to plead guilty or go to trial?

Potential for Reduced Penalties: Often, prosecutors will offer a reduced sentence if you plead guilty, especially in exchange for cooperating with their case or taking responsibility for your actions. If you are facing serious charges, a plea deal might be more appealing than risking a lengthy sentence at trial.

How often do judges accept plea deals?

It is often said and widely accepted that ninety percent (90%) of criminal cases never make it to trial, due to plea bargaining. A plea bargain is an agreement between a defendant and the prosecutor for a lighter punishment in exchange for something else: usually a guilty plea, cooperation, or assistance of some kind.

Why would a prosecutor not offer a plea bargain?

Prosecutors usually check with victims about plea deals. If a victim is against it and the case is strong a prosecutor may just choose to go to trial. Sometimes they have office policies especially on certain types of cases against deals.

What are the disadvantages of accepting a plea bargain?

Cons of Entering Into a Plea Bargain
  • Innocence. If you are truly innocent of the crime you are being charged with, it can be hard to accept a plea agreement—even for a reduced sentence or charge.
  • Loss of rights. ...
  • Criminal record. ...
  • Criminal sentence.