Can an employer change the reason for termination after the fact?

Asked by: Nestor Hirthe  |  Last update: April 15, 2025
Score: 5/5 (29 votes)

If an employer shifts rationales for its decision or tries to pile on by adding new reasons after the fact, it will likely have to explain itself to a jury or pay to settle the case. A recent decision from a federal court in Tennessee, Rikita Bonner-Gibson v. Genesis Engineering Group, illustrates this principle.

Can an employer change the reason for termination?

California is an At Will State. Unless it is outlined otherwise as part of an employment contract or collective bargaining agreement, employment in California is at will. An employer does not have to provide a valid reason for terminating an employee, and an employee does not have to give notice before resigning.

What is an example of unfair termination?

Examples of wrongful termination

Your termination could be wrongful if your employer fired you: Due to discrimination. In violation of a federal or state labor law. Because you reported and refused to participate in harassment.

Can a job termination be reversed?

Filing a wrongful termination lawsuit can help you get your job back. However, it is only a guaranteed outcome of a successful lawsuit in a small set of cases. In some instances, the employer may offer you your job back in order to settle the lawsuit.

Can an employer change their mind about dismissal?

Unless it can be shown that the termination represented anything other than conscious or rational decision by the employer, an employer will not be able to unilaterally retract its notice of termination even if the termination notice is based on a mistake.

Tech Worker Records Her "Termination" and Goes Viral. Here's Where It Went Wrong.

32 related questions found

Can an employer lied about reason for termination?

Can My Employer Lie About Why I'm Being Fired? An employer is allowed to lie about why an employee is terminated. However, the law is clear that lying about why an employee was fired can be evidence of “pretext,” meaning that the employer is hiding the real reason for the termination.

How to appeal unfair dismissal?

Appealing a dismissal

If an employee thinks their dismissal was unfair and wants to challenge it, they can appeal through their employer's appeal process. The employer should tell them how to appeal. Being able to appeal a dismissal is also part of the Acas Code of Practice.

Can HR overturn a termination?

Can HR reverse a termination? According to Los Angeles employment attorney Todd M. Friedman, reversing a termination can occur when an employer acknowledges that the grounds for termination were unfounded, unjustified, or made in error. However, this process is complex and only suitable under specific circumstances.

What are my rights if I am terminated?

If you are fired or laid off, your employer must pay all wages due to you immediately upon termination (California Labor Code Section 201). If you quit, and gave your employer 72 hours of notice, you are entitled on your last day to all wages due.

Can an employer revoke a termination letter?

They cannot force the employee to return by simply revoking their dismissal if the termination has already taken effect. A termination takes effect when the employee stops working or on the date mentioned in the termination letter.

What not to say in termination?

11 Things You Should Never Say When Firing an Employee
  • “This is really hard for me.” ...
  • “I'm not sure how to say this.” ...
  • “We've decided to let you go.” ...
  • “We've decided to go in a different direction.” ...
  • “We'll work out the details later.” ...
  • “Compared to Susan, your performance is subpar.”

What is the most you can sue for wrongful termination?

While multimillion awards are possible, it is crucial to keep in mind that federal laws limit the amount of punitive and compensatory damages awarded in cases involving wrongful termination. They cannot exceed $50,000 – $300,000, depending on the number of employees working for the employer's business.

What are 5 automatically unfair dismissal?

Automatically unfair reasons for dismissal

family, including parental leave, paternity leave (birth and adoption), adoption leave or time off for dependants. acting as an employee representative. acting as a trade union representative. acting as an occupational pension scheme trustee.

Can previous employer give reason for termination?

In many cases, if you were fired or terminated from employment, the company can say so. They can also give a reason. For example, if someone was fired for stealing or falsifying a timesheet, the company can explain why the employee was terminated.

Can my employer change my job role without my consent?

Without the employee's consent, the employer may change the requirements, duties, schedule, pay, title, or job location. They can also terminate the employee at will, as long as it's not for an illegal reason (such as discrimination, retaliation, or anything covered by FLSA, ADA, and other compliance frameworks).

Can you revoke a termination notice?

Either partner can revoke (cancel) the filing of a Notice of Termination of Domestic Partnership, for any reason, at any time before the end of the six-month period that starts when the notice is filed with the California Secretary of State.

Do I have the right to know why I was fired?

Contrary to popular belief, employers generally do not have to give a reason or explanation to employees who are being fired. In nearly all states, employment is presumed to be “at will,” meaning you or your employer can end the employment relationship at any time, and for whatever lawful reason.

What is my manager not allowed to do?

Your boss may not punish you or retaliate against you in any for having conversations about salary. Your boss is also not allowed under the law to question you about any conversation you may have had, threaten you for having it, or put you under surveillance for such conversations.

Can you appeal a termination?

Contesting a termination often leads to legal action and can remedy the situation on behalf of the employee, depending on the circumstances. It is not a guaranteed solution-around 70% of wrongful termination litigation is successful for the employee-and can be a stressful and costly process.

How to win wrongful termination?

One of the most effective ways to support your wrongful termination case is through detailed documentation. Keeping a record of your job performance, disciplinary actions, and interactions with supervisors or HR departments can strengthen your claim.

Can a company reverse a termination?

Reversing a termination can happen when an employer realizes the grounds for termination were unfounded, unjustified, or made in error. However, it is complicated and only appropriate under certain circumstances.

Can an employer withdraw a notice of termination?

Once a valid notice has been given, it cannot be withdrawn by only one party, whether the employer or the employee. The notice period can, during the operational period of that notice, only be shortened or extended by mutual consent.

How do you prove a dismissal was unfair?

he dismissal will be regarded as automatically unfair if the worker is dismissed for:
  1. exercising any of the rights given by the LRA or participating in proceedings in terms of the Act.
  2. taking part in lawful union activities.
  3. taking part in a legal strike or other industrial action or protest action.

How to sue your employer for wrongful termination?

Steps to Take if You Believe You've Been Wrongfully Terminated
  1. Understand Your Employee Rights. ...
  2. Gather Evidence to Fortify Your Wrongful Termination Lawsuit. ...
  3. Consult a Wrongful Termination Lawyer. ...
  4. File a Complaint with HR. ...
  5. Explore Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) ...
  6. File a Complaint with a Government Agency.

Can I claim unfair dismissal?

If you were sacked because of an automatically unfair reason, you can make an unfair dismissal claim. Check how to challenge your dismissal. If you were sacked for a discriminatory reason, you can make a claim for discrimination.