Can you be tried again if new evidence is found?
Asked by: Gideon Bode | Last update: January 19, 2026Score: 4.8/5 (12 votes)
The obvious application of double jeopardy is when law enforcement finds new evidence of the defendant's guilt after the jury has already acquitted them. The prosecution cannot charge them again, even if the evidence shows that they probably are guilty.
Can you be tried twice if new evidence is found?
In California law, this protection is codified in Penal Code 687 PC, which states: "No person can be subjected to a second prosecution for a public offense for which he has once been prosecuted and convicted or acquitted." The double jeopardy principle protects people from being prosecuted twice for the same crime.
What happens when new evidence is found?
New evidence can produce several outcomes on a criminal appeal. If the evidence is compelling, the appellate court may order a new trial or reverse the original verdict. The court will review the latest evidence to determine if it creates reasonable doubt about the defendant's guilt.
Can a case be reopened with new evidence?
Reopening settled cases can occur when significant new evidence comes to light that wasn't available before. Sometimes, this might mean holding other parties liable, which can aid the victim in their financial recovery. This can occur in a car accident, for example.
Can an acquittal be overturned with new evidence?
So the answer to your question is no. The concept of double jeopardy applies. If the jury says 'not guilty' then that's pretty much it, barring some exceptions which are unlikely to have taken place in your murder trial.
Karen Read Retrial Evidence | Vinnie Politan Investigates
Can you be tried for the same crime twice if new evidence is found in the UK?
The rule against double jeopardy is only lifted once in respect of each qualifying offence: even if there is a subsequent discovery of new evidence, the prosecution may not apply for an order quashing the acquittal and seeking a retrial section 75(3).
Can you retry an acquittal?
Retrial after acquittal. Once acquitted, a defendant may not be retried for the same offense: "A verdict of acquittal, although not followed by any judgment, is a bar to a subsequent prosecution for the same offense." This applies in all cases where a verdict of not guilty is entered by the Court against a defendant.
When can a judge consider newly discovered evidence?
Gray, 51 MJ 1 (to warrant a new trial on the grounds of newly discovered evidence, appellant must show: (1) the evidence was discovered after the trial; (2) the evidence is not such that it would have been discovered by the petitioner at the time of trial in the exercise of due diligence; and (3) the newly discovered ...
Can laws change with new evidence?
If new evidence contradicts a theory, it can be changed. A scientific law is a short statement that proves how something is true. These are typically mathematical formulas and if new evidence contradicts a law, then it is no longer considered a law. A scientific law must always be true.
Can a case be reopened after found not guilty?
A defendant whose conviction was reversed on appeal may be retried without violating double jeopardy. However, any charge of which the defendant was found not guilty the first time cannot be retried.
What can change with new evidence?
Accepted theories may be modified or overturned as new evidence and perspective emerges. Scientists are likely to accept a new or modified theory if it explains everything the old theory did and more.
What is new evidence called in court?
After-discovered evidence, or newly discovered evidence, is evidence which existed at the time of the original trial but was only discovered after the conclusion of the trial. After-discovered evidence is an issue predominantly in criminal proceedings and may be used as the basis for a motion for a new trial .
What happened after discovery?
What Happens After the Discovery Phase in a Lawsuit? At the end of the discovery process, both parties should have a reasonably good idea of the strength of their opponent's case as well as their own. A weakness in one party's position may encourage it to try negotiating a settlement to avoid going to trial.
When can a case not be tried again?
If a defendant is acquitted, whether by a jury verdict or a judge's ruling, the protection against double jeopardy is fully realized. The government cannot appeal an acquittal or subject the defendant to a new trial for the same offense.
Can I sue after being found not guilty?
If you are accused of a crime and acquitted or otherwise found not guilty of the offense, you can still face a civil lawsuit for the same incident. The Double Jeopardy clause only protects you from subsequent criminal prosecution in the legal system.
What amendment says you can't be tried twice?
The Double Jeopardy Clause in the Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution prohibits anyone from being prosecuted twice for substantially the same crime .
Can a judge rule against evidence?
The court may make any statement about the character or form of the evidence, the objection made, and the ruling. The court may direct that an offer of proof be made in question-and-answer form. (d) Preventing the Jury from Hearing Inadmissible Evidence.
What happens when a new law contradicts an old law?
If there really is no other way to reconcile them, then the more recent law takes precedence because it's held to have implicitly repealed the old one to the extent of the contradiction.
What are the 7 laws of nature explained?
The 7 laws of nature include the Law of Cause and Effect, Relativity, Attraction, Rhythm, Polarity, Gender, and Perpetual Transmutation of Energy. Economic laws are similar to scientific laws in that they seek to create a relation between two or more phenomena.
What type of court does not accept new evidence?
Unlike trial courts, appellate courts do not retry cases or hear new evidence; they do not hear witnesses testify; and there is no jury.
What is considered new evidence?
Here's what we mean by “new and relevant” evidence: New evidence is information we haven't considered before. Relevant evidence is information that proves or disproves something in your claim.
What type of evidence can clear a defendant from blame or fault?
In criminal law , exculpatory evidence is evidence , such as a statement, tending to excuse , justify, or absolve the alleged fault or guilt of a defendant . In other words, the evidence is favorable to the defendant.
Can you be retried if new evidence is found?
A retrial is only possible by ground of a 'novum': the situation in which new evidence has come to light and in which it seems that, had the judge known of this evidence, the defendant would have been prosecuted.
Can evidence be used twice?
Under current law, a defendant, whether acquitted or convicted at a first trial, may be confronted with identical evidence at a second trial for an offense that could have been joined and tried in the initial prosecution. The clause bars such an action only if the offenses in each trial are the 'same.
How many times can a case be retried?
How many times can a defendant be retried? For those facing hung jury retrials, it's as many times as the government pleases. Double jeopardy prohibitions do not apply when juries fail to reach a verdict. There is, theoretically, a built-in procedural solution to stop the government from endlessly retrying defendants.