Do most child custody cases go to trial?

Asked by: Mrs. Tania West Sr.  |  Last update: February 1, 2025
Score: 4.2/5 (26 votes)

Determining Custody By comparison, only 4% of custody cases require going to trial before primary custody is decided. Overall, 91% of custody decisions do not require the family court to decide.

Who is most likely to win a custody battle?

Mothers historically have won more custody battles due to traditional roles and perceptions of mothers as the primary caregivers. However, this trend is changing as courts increasingly focus on the best interests of the child, considering many factors beyond traditional roles.

Why would a custody battle go to trial?

Child custody cases where physical and/or emotional abuse to a child OR a parent has occurred are likely to go to trial as well. A finding of physical/emotional abuse has serious ramifications with respect to custody, both legal and physical.

What is the biggest mistake in a custody battle?

The Most Common Mistakes Made in California Child Custody Cases. Failing to respond to a child custody case will not make the issue go away. Instead, it could lead to a default judgment. This means that whatever the other party is requesting will most likely be granted by the judge because you have not given any input.

What not to say during a custody battle?

Avoid cursing and putting down the other parent, your children, in-laws, and other family members, the mediator, the judge, and others involved in the process. That can be tricky when sensitive topics, such as substance abuse, are at play.

A Basic Guide to Child Custody Trials

43 related questions found

How many child custody cases go to trial?

Determining Custody

11% are determined with the assistance of a mediator, and 5% are determined following a custody evaluation. By comparison, only 4% of custody cases require going to trial before primary custody is decided. Overall, 91% of custody decisions do not require the family court to decide.

How a mother can lose a custody battle?

Serious neglect is proper grounds for a mother to lose custody. There is no "perfect parent" standard in the California Family Code. Family law judges understand parenting is an imperfect process.

What to say in court to win child custody?

Good Words To Use In Custody Hearing
  • Your Child is Not Property. The primary thing you must remember is that your child is not property. ...
  • Best Interests of Child. With that in mind, you must always remember in Court, it is about your children. ...
  • Status Quo. ...
  • Child's Schedule. ...
  • Co-Parenting. ...
  • Flexibility. ...
  • Step-Up Plan. ...
  • Our Child.

What not to say in child support court?

Don't Bash The Other Parent

Even if what you are saying is true, it is best to allow the courts to discover any undue behaviors on the part of parents during child custody hearings. Also, while refraining from making true claims about the other parent, it is not a good idea to make false defamatory claims against them.

How do most custody battles end?

Some courts have mediation programs, and others require you to find an outside mediator. The court will choose your mediator if you and the other parent cannot agree. If you reach an agreement, you can file it with the court to end your case. If you don't agree, the court process will continue.

Who are the best witnesses for a child custody trial?

Picking good witnesses, like family, coaches, doctors, social workers, psychologists, counselors, or the kids' school personnel, can help a lot. They can tell the court about the kids' circumstances and what's in their best interest.

What looks bad in a custody battle?

Bad-mouthing your ex-spouse or engaging in verbal or physical altercations with them in front of a judge looks bad. If your children are present, it looks even worse. Judges understand that tempers run high during custody cases, but lack of self-control will not reflect favorably.

Why do men lose custody battles?

Primary Caregiver Presumption: Most times at the point of a separation fathers defer to the mother as the primary caregiver. This ends up putting them at a disadvantage because courts often presume the parent who has been the primary caregiver is better suited for custody.

Which gender wins more custody battles?

In fact, on the national average, a female parent is granted around 65% of custody time, whereas a male parent receives around 35%. Blogs covered in this blog: Numerous States award shared custody, with both female and male parents each granted a full 50% of the time with their children.

Is it hard to fight for custody?

In most cases, physical and legal custody are awarded to one parent or shared between both parents. However, there are some cases where one parent is awarded sole physical and legal custody of a child. Fighting for child custody can be a long and difficult process.

What makes a strong custody case?

In California, evidence against the other parent showing sexual or physical abuse, neglect, addictions or other serious issues are necessary to pave your way toward getting primary or sole physical custody of your children.

What not to say in child custody mediation?

DON'T refer to the children as “my” children. Another red flag for the mediator – someone who seems possessive of the children will not be found to be the parent who fosters a relationship between the children and the other parent – one of the statutory factors the Court must consider when fashioning a custody order.

How do you play dirty in a custody battle?

Examples of Tricks Used in Custody Battles
  1. Maxing out joint credit cards and cleaning out shared bank accounts.
  2. Moving out with the children and taking them to another state.
  3. Making false claims of domestic violence or child abuse.
  4. Getting a restraining order based on false allegations.

Is it worth fighting for custody?

A court battle over child custody has many drawbacks, though, and should be your last resort. But if you and your spouse can't negotiate a parenting plan, you'll want to be aware of what you're facing and have an idea of what to expect when you head to court.

Can a parent lose custody for false accusations?

California courts can impose consequences on a parent who makes false accusations against the other. One common outcome is a reduction in custody rights for the accuser, as judges are keen to prevent one parent from using dishonest tactics to gain an advantage.

Can you lose custody for not having a job?

While financial stability is a factor in custody cases, unemployment alone is rarely enough to disqualify a parent from custody. Judges consider several factors, such as a parent's ability to provide a safe, loving environment and meet the child's emotional needs.

Who usually wins in a custody battle?

Currently, single mothers tend to rely on the system more, and the process is said to be difficult for a mother to navigate through. Even though women tend to win most custody battles, getting there can be tough.

What percentage of cases never go to trial?

By some estimates, only 2% to 3% of criminal cases go to trial. It's no secret that the overwhelming majority of criminal cases never reach trial. The prosecution may dismiss charges, perhaps because of a lack of evidence.

Who is most likely to get full custody?

Courts cannot discriminate against a parent based on gender. Yet the best-interest-of-the-child standard is more likely to favor mothers since they are often the primary caregivers for children. For a father in a custody battle, proving parental fitness is key.