What do psychologists say about people who watch true crime?

Asked by: Miss Ottilie Mohr PhD  |  Last update: June 1, 2026
Score: 4.5/5 (48 votes)

The psychology behind true crime fascination involves morbid curiosity, a safe way to process fear, the brain's survival instinct to learn about threats, and a desire for justice and control in chaotic situations, often driven by empathy for victims, especially for women who are disproportionately targeted, offering lessons in vigilance and understanding the darker side of human nature. It's a mix of thrill-seeking (adrenaline rush) and problem-solving (figuring out motives), providing catharsis and moral clarity.

What does watching true crime say about you?

While curiosity about real-life mysteries is normal, finding comfort in violent or disturbing stories might point to something deeper — like emotional numbness or a subconscious attraction to chaos.

What is the psychology of true crime fans?

"True crime fans show a higher ability to deal with anxiety and stress in their daily lives. This could indicate a training mechanism through the playful engagement with crime," says Perchtold-Stefan. However, further studies are needed to test this hypothesis.

Is watching true crime bad for mental health?

In most cases, according to Bansal, the psychological impact of watching a little too much true crime can vary. ``Yes, it can contribute to existing anxiety disorders, mild depression, furthering a negative view of the world. While it can't cause depression, it can be a contributing factor.

What do psychologists say about true crime?

Psychologist Dr. Meg Arroll told ``true crime stories allow us to explore the darker side of nature in a safe way'', and psychologist Emma Kenny told that watching crime shows can ``trigger chemical reactions in our bodies, while also affirming our moral views about right and wrong''.

6 Reasons Why People Enjoy True Crime Stories | Psychology of Murder Mystery | #DeepDives

27 related questions found

What kind of person likes true crime?

They want justice to prevail

When innocent people are victimized, people who follow true crime feel genuine outrage. They want to see justice served, but they also don't want a rush to judgment.

What is the #1 worst habit for anxiety?

While there's no single "number one" worst habit, procrastination/avoidance and poor sleep/deprivation are consistently cited as extremely detrimental, often creating a vicious cycle where anxiety causes the habit, which then worsens the anxiety. Other major culprits include excessive caffeine, negative self-talk, unhealthy eating, clutter, and substance misuse, all of which disrupt mental and physical regulation, making anxiety symptoms stronger.
 

What personality type likes true crime?

They are empathetic and believe in justice

On the opposite side of the spectrum, true crime viewers are also very empathetic. It might sound counterintuitive, but Bonn believes that's why so many women are drawn to true crime: they're more empathetic.

What type of people listen to true crime?

For example, women make up nearly their entire fanbase – almost 75% of true crime podcast listeners are WOMEN. At CrimeCon, an annual event with speakers and crime experts that attracts more than 5,000 people, about 75% are women, according to data shared by the conference.

Why do traumatized people like true crime?

One of the most basic reasons behind why people enjoy true crime stories is that they want to “know how and why it happens.” Within most humans exists the desire to empathize with other human beings and true crime stories allow people to do this without actually experiencing the trauma themselves.

What personality disorder is linked to crime?

People with antisocial personality disorder often violate the law, becoming criminals. They may lie, behave violently or impulsively, and have problems with drug and alcohol use. They have difficulty consistently meeting responsibilities related to family, work or school.

Who watches true crime the most?

#1– True Crime cuts across age and gender

52%) and adults under 65 than older adults (61% vs. 42%) consume true crime, But interest and viewership is high among younger audiences too. Only the oldest audiences — 65+ — seems to eschew True Crime.

Is watching true crime a red flag to relax?

Psychologist Dr. Thema Bryant has cautioned against using true crime shows as a way to unwind, suggesting it could be a red flag for unresolved emotional issues. She explained that finding relaxation in depictions of trauma might indicate familiarity with such experiences, potentially signaling a need for counseling.

What happens when you watch too much true crime?

Excessive exposure to true crime can distort your perception of reality, making the world seem far more dangerous than it actually is. In reality, most people will never experience the violent crimes portrayed in these stories, but when you hear about them daily, it can feel like danger is just around the corner.

Is being obsessed with true crime bad?

Whether it's serial killers or unsolved mysteries, true crime taps into our fascination with the darker side of human behavior. Fans' obsessions and awareness, however, may lead to anxiety and paranoia. Further, romanticizing criminals in the media can make light of serious cases.

What kind of person enjoys true crime?

Women are more prone to enjoy and obsess over true crime than men because they are disproportionately likely to be victims of crime. The driving force behind this obsession is the desire to experience fear in a controlled environment, where we can safely explore unsettling emotions without real danger.

What personality disorder is most common in serial killers?

However, very few serial killers are considered mentally ill enough to be declared legally insane. Rather, the majority display signs of psychopathy or sociopathy; in terms of diagnosis, they may meet the criteria for antisocial personality disorder.

What is the psychology of liking true crime?

Tuggle said that true crime's appeal stems from a sense of justice and feeling that the justice system broke down in some cases. “The murderer winds up not paying consequences,” Tuggle said. “Maybe it's ineptitude by the investigators or prosecutors, or even malfeasance where people get bribed.

What is the 3-3-3 rule for habits?

The "3-3-3 rule" for habits refers to the stages of forming a new behavior: the first 3 days are the hardest, consistency for 3 weeks makes it a routine, and doing it for 3 months (around 90 days) locks it in as an automatic part of your life, requiring less willpower. It's a mental framework to manage overwhelming goals by focusing on short, achievable milestones (3 days, then 3 weeks, then 3 months) to build momentum and make the habit stick. 

What are top 10 brain damaging habits?

10 Habits That Can Hurt Your Brain

  • Habit #1: Not Sleeping Enough. ...
  • Habit #2: Smoking. ...
  • Habit #3: Spending Too Much Time Alone. ...
  • Habit #4: Being Too Stationary. ...
  • Habit #5: Overeating. ...
  • Habit #6: Eating Too Much Junk Food. ...
  • Habit #7: Blasting Your Headphones. ...
  • Habit #8: Spending Too Much Time in the Dark.

What are 5 signs you have anxiety?

Five common anxiety symptoms include feeling nervous/restless, an increased heart rate, rapid breathing, sweating/trembling, and trouble concentrating, often accompanied by persistent worry, fatigue, or digestive issues, impacting daily life with physical and mental distress.
 

What are the three signs of a psychopath?

Three key signs of psychopathy include a profound lack of empathy and remorse, a pattern of manipulative and deceitful behavior (like pathological lying), and a disregard for social norms, rules, or others' rights, often masked by superficial charm and grandiosity. These traits manifest as callousness, impulsivity, irresponsibility, and a tendency to exploit others without feeling guilt. 

Do serial killers have a higher IQ?

No, serial killers do not inherently have high IQs; their intelligence levels vary widely, much like the general population, but studies show their average IQ tends to be around normal or slightly below average (90-100), despite media portrayals of super-intelligent killers like Hannibal Lecter. While some famous examples like Ted Bundy had higher IQs (around 136) and used their intelligence to evade capture, many others fall within the average range, with some organized killers even having slightly higher averages (around 113) and disorganized killers having lower ones (around 93).
 

What syndrome has been linked to serial killers?

Antisocial personality disorder

It's also been diagnosed among three of the most ruthless American serial killers: Ted Bundy, an infamous killer and necrophile, confessed to 30 murders in the 1970s. John Wayne Gacy, known as the “Killer Clown,” raped and killed 33 boys and young men in the 1970s.