What means jury nullification?

Asked by: Frieda Zulauf  |  Last update: July 27, 2022
Score: 4.3/5 (4 votes)

A jury's knowing and deliberate rejection of the evidence or refusal to apply the law either because the jury wants to send a message about some social issue that is larger than the case itself, or because the result dictated by law is contrary to the jury's sense of justice, morality, or fairness.

What is an example of jury nullification?

Jury nullification takes place when jurors acquit a defendant who is factually guilty because they disagree with the law as written. For example, during Prohibition, juries who disagreed with alcohol control laws often acquitted defendants who had been caught red handed smuggling alcohol.

What is jury nullification and why is it important?

Jury nullification occurs when a jury returns a verdict of "Not Guilty" despite its belief that the defendant is guilty of the violation charged. The jury in effect nullifies a law that it believes is either immoral or wrongly applied to the defendant whose fate they are charged with deciding.

Why is jury nullification a good thing?

Jury nullification provides a process that can protect the father from punishment, even though his attack after the abuse is technically a crime as well. 2. It prevents personal bias from entering into the conviction process.

Is jury nullification a problem?

Jury nullification is a legal problem child. Aberrant but built into the Constitution, rebellious but merciful, lawless but often just, it defies easy categorization. Courts have been reluctant to discuss this unruly character, preferring that it remain in the shadows.

Jury Nullification Basics in Under 6 Minutes

32 related questions found

Why is jury nullification controversial?

Arguments against nullification include that it would lead to anarchy; that it is unwise or unnecessary; that it is necessary, but better left implicit; or that an instruction on nullification would impair the responsibility of the jurors by confusing them on their duties.

Can the judge overrule the jury?

No. Once a verdict has been rendered, either guilty or not guilty, the judge cannot overrule the jury. However, under California law, a defendant can make a motion for judgment of acquittal before the evidence is submitted to the jury.

Is nullification legal?

Nullification is a legal doctrine, which argues that states have the ability — and duty — to invalidate national actions they deem unconstitutional. In its most overt manifestation, this form of resistance is used by state leaders to dispute perceived federal overreach and reject federal authority.

Can jury nullification be justified?

Nullification is inherently undemocratic, even if it is morally justified in a particular case. Sometimes, nullification is a tool that juries can use to set aside a law they believe is immoral or wrongly applied to the accused.

What is it called when a judge overrule a jury?

In American courts, JNOV is the practice whereby the presiding judge in a civil jury trial may overrule the decision of a jury and reverse or amend their verdict. In literal terms, the judge enters a judgment notwithstanding the jury verdict.

What does nullification mean?

Definition of nullification

1 : the act of nullifying : the state of being nullified. 2 : the action of a state impeding or attempting to prevent the operation and enforcement within its territory of a law of the U.S.

Is jury nullification ethical?

The main ethical issue involved in jury nullification is the tension between democratic self-government and integrity. The argument has been raised that prosecutors are not allowed to seek jury nullification, and therefore defendants should not be allowed to seek it either.

Where does jury nullification come from?

The tradition of jury nullification in the United States has its roots in the British legal system, specifically in a 1670 English case where Quakers were acquitted by a jury of violating a law that permitted religious assemblies only under the Church of England.

What options are available to the court if a jury engages in jury nullification?

What options are available to the court if a jury engages in jury nullification? Jurors are allowed to read peer-reviewed scholarly works (journals) to expand their knowledge on the subject at hand.

How do jurors reach a verdict of guilty or not guilty?

The jurors meet in a room outside the courtroom to decide whether the prosecutor has proven beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused is guilty. All the jurors must agree on the decision or verdict – their decision must be unanimous.

Do you get paid for jury duty?

Yes. By law, employers must pay employees who are undertaking jury service. You are considered to be employed or apprenticed during any time when you are absent from your job in order to comply with a jury summons. Note: Your employer is only obliged to pay you for the time you attended at court for jury service.

What is the opposite of jury nullification?

Reverse nullification licenses juries to apply their own personal prejudices and idiosyncratic values rather than the orderly, unbiased, application of fact to law.

What is an example of nullification?

Nullification is the act of cancelling something. Counteracting the effects of a snakebite with an antidote could be described as nullification, for example. Use the noun nullification when one thing overcomes or overrides another, basically erasing the effects of the first thing.

How does nullification work?

Nullification is usually considered to be an act by a state finding a federal law unconstitutional, and declaring it void and unenforceable in that state. A nullification act often makes it illegal to enforce the federal law in question. Nullification arguably may be undertaken by a single state.

What area of the United States supported nullification?

The doctrine of nullification had been advocated by Thomas Jefferson and James Madison in the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions of 1798–99.

Can a jury be biased?

When the jury member brings outside evidence that they may have found themselves into the trial which has not been allowed by the judges or lawyers and is used to create bias on the part of the juror. This new information may be used to influence their final decision.

What happens if jurors Cannot agree?

A judge is unable to force the jury to return a verdict. If a jury cannot agree on a verdict, either unanimously or by a permissible majority, the whole jury will be discharged. A jury who are unable to agree on a verdict are known as a hung jury.

Does the jury have the final say?

In short, the jurors determine the facts and reach a verdict, within the guidelines of the law as determined by the judge. Many states allow the lawyers to request that certain instructions be given, but the judge makes the final decisions about them.

Is jury nullification a threat to the rule of law?

Despite an intractable judiciary, there is widespread consensus within the legal academy that jury nullification is compatible with the rule of law. This proposi- tion is most strongly tested by “substantive nullifications,” where a jury nullifies simply because it disagrees with the law itself.

Is jury nullification legal in California?

However, since 2001 it has been well-settled that jury nullification is not sanctioned by California law. That year, the state's Supreme Court announced its decision in People v. Williams.