What situations is lying acceptable?

Asked by: Wilburn Legros  |  Last update: August 31, 2023
Score: 4.9/5 (52 votes)

Many deemed it acceptable to lie to people who were emotionally fragile, near death, or would be confused by the truth. They also found it more ethical to lie when doing so would help others save face in public or concentrate on something important.

What lies are acceptable?

They're minor evasions told to avoid hurting someone's feelings or to avoid conflict. For example, you say “Of course, I'm not angry you were 40 minutes late.” Behavioral experts seem to agree that these “white lies” are acceptable in moderation to preserve social harmony.

In what situations do people lie?

Sometimes it's to protect the liar from being punished, or to protect someone else from punishment. The lie might be to avoid being embarrassed, to hide an awkward situation, or to simply have others think better of the person telling the fib. Such lying isn't admirable, but not hard to understand why it occurs.

What is justifiable lying?

Depending on the moral theory used, lying in special circumstances (for example, “white” lies or lies that benefit others or avert harm) might be morally justifiable. Other lies, as lying about one's age in order to get access to age-restricted goods, are most often immoral.

What is a practical example of lying?

You refuse to admit that you shoplifted an item and instead say that you watched someone else take it. You lie about your financial assets in a divorce, saying you actually have much less money than you do, in order to avoid giving your spouse his or her share of the marital assets that you both own.

Jordan Peterson - Side Effects of Telling Lies

32 related questions found

What is the most common form of lie?

88.6 % of reported lies in the study were described as “little white lies,” and 11.4 % were characterized as “big lies.” An example of a “little white lie” would be saying you like a gift you really don't, and an example of a “big lie” would be insincerely declaring "I love you" to someone.

What are the 6 general kinds of lie?

Let's talk about the different kinds of lies and see if you recognize them.
  • Types of Lies. ...
  • White Lies. ...
  • Broken Promises. ...
  • The Lie of Fabrication. ...
  • The Bold-Faced Lie. ...
  • The Lying in Exaggeration. ...
  • Lies of Deception. ...
  • Plagiarism.

Is it ever morally acceptable to lie?

Utilitarians base their reasoning on the claim that actions, including lying, are morally acceptable when the resulting consequences maximize benefit or minimize harm. A lie, therefore, is not always immoral; in fact, when lying is necessary to maximize benefit or minimize harm, it may be immoral not to lie.

What is lying with good intentions?

Some people who lie often do so with good intentions. We call these "white lies", or lies that occur when the person wants to avoid causing someone else pain. A husband may lie to spare his wife's feelings, or a father may lie to avoid his child's tears.

Why is lying well helpful?

“Prosocial lying reflects the development of at least four distinct human capacities: theory of mind, empathy, compassion, and the combination of memory and imagination that allows us to foresee the consequences of our words.”

What are the top 3 reasons people lie?

However, of the most common motives for telling lies, avoiding punishment is the primary motivator for both children and adults. Other typical reasons include protecting ourselves or others from harm, maintaining privacy, and avoiding embarrassment, to name a few.

What is the rule for lie lying?

The present participle of lie is not lieing. The i becomes a y: lying. Here is a mnemonic to help you tell laying and lying apart: “If you tell an untruth, it is a lie, not a lay; and if you are in the process of telling an untruth you are lying, not laying.

Is lying a defense mechanism?

Why do we lie? Lying allows a person to establish perceived control over a situation by manipulating it. It's a defence mechanism that (seemingly) prevents them from being vulnerable, that is, to not open up and reveal their true self to another person.

What are positive lies?

We tell positive white lies to people about how good they are or how wonderful they look with the simple aim that they feel better about themselves. When we value the happiness of others, telling them the truth can be uncomfortable.

What is the ethicality of lying?

Lying is bad because a generally truthful world is a good thing: lying diminishes trust between human beings: if people generally didn't tell the truth, life would become very difficult, as nobody could be trusted and nothing you heard or read could be trusted - you would have to find everything out for yourself.

What is an example of a benevolent lie?

A plausible, if rather extreme, example of lying for the good is if a murderer asks you which way his intended victim has gone, and you show him in the opposite. A less clear-cut instance would be a military draftee pretending medical disability to avoid having to kill in active service.

Can you lie without intent?

So, lying often occurs intentionally, but some lies may not be expressed with the intention to create a false belief in another person's mind. Most definitions of lying provided by deception experts and dictionaries include that lying occurs intentionally, i.e., deliberately making an untruthful statement to deceive.

How do you know if you're good at lying?

The 18 Traits of Good Liars
  • Manipulativeness. Manipulators frequently tell lies, tend to persist in lying when challenged to tell the truth, and don't feel uncomfortable or guilty when lying.
  • Acting. ...
  • Expressiveness. ...
  • Physical attractiveness. ...
  • Natural performers. ...
  • Experience. ...
  • Confidence. ...
  • Emotional camouflage.

What are the two main types of lies?

There are two primary ways to lie: to conceal and to falsify. In concealing, the liar withholds some information without actually saying anything untrue. In falsifying, an additional step is taken. Not only does the liar withhold true information, but one presents false information as if it were true.

Is it ever OK to lie to someone?

Lying is OK in two general situations, to protect yourself or someone else from immediate danger — e.g., your friend's abusive spouse asks if you know where your friend is — and to protect someone's feelings.

Is it toxic to lie?

Lying. Dishonesty degrades the foundation of all relationships, mutual trust. Philosopher Immanuel Kant believed if everyone lied, nobody would believe anything they were told! Lying is toxic since it is self-defeating. Striving for truth in our relationships with others shows we care about their desires and choices.

Is lying ever morally permissible while lying can be seen as?

Is lying ever morally permissible? While lying can be seen as a threat to civil society, there seem to be several instances in which lying seems the most intuitively moral option.

What are the red flags of lying?

When it comes to detecting lies, people often focus on body language “tells,” or subtle physical and behavioral signs that reveal deception. For example, shrugging, lack of expression, a bored posture, and grooming behaviors such as playing with hair or pressing fingers to lips can give away a person who is lying.

What is a GREY lie?

Gray lies were said to consist of lies that were ambiguous in nature or held the characteristics of a real lie yet were still viewed as justifiable given the circumstance.

How do narcissists lie?

Pathological chronic lying

Narcissists can be very cunning, sly, and resourceful in inventing lies. They are manipulative, deceitful, and unscrupulous to alienate their victims and influence observers. They start by lying about themselves, then move on to lying about their ex, their career, and their accomplishments.