Why are settlements illegal?
Asked by: Prof. Adalberto Wintheiser | Last update: February 20, 2026Score: 4.9/5 (61 votes)
Settlements are considered illegal under international law primarily because they violate the Fourth Geneva Convention, which forbids an occupying power from transferring its own population into occupied territory, a practice seen in Israeli settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem. Major international bodies, including the UN Security Council and the International Court of Justice, have affirmed this, stating settlements lack legal validity and impede peace efforts, though Israel disputes this interpretation, citing other legal arguments and security concerns.
Why are Israeli settlements illegal under international law?
Israeli settlements in the Israeli-occupied Palestinian territories of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip (former), as well as in the Syrian Golan Heights, are illegal under international law. These settlements are in violation of Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention, and in breach of international declarations.
What is an illegal settlement?
Illegal settlements may refer to: Settler colonialism. Ba'athist Arabization campaigns in northern Iraq. Indonesian transmigration program. Israeli settlements, in the West Bank, illegal under international law.
Why can't Israel give up the West Bank?
Though its occupation is illegal, Israel has cited several reasons for retaining the West Bank within its ambit: historic rights stemming from the Balfour Declaration; security grounds, both internal and external; and the area's symbolic value for Jews.
Why do Israelis claim Palestine as their land?
Israelis believe Palestine (the Land of Israel/Canaan) is theirs due to deep religious ties (God's promise to Abraham), a continuous 3,000-year-old Jewish presence and sovereignty in ancient times (Kingdoms of Israel/Judah), the Zionist movement's goal of a Jewish national home, and international legal recognition via the Balfour Declaration and League of Nations Mandate, all reinforcing a sense of historical and divine right to self-determination in the land.
What If Everything You Think About West Bank Settlers Is Wrong? | Unpacked
Whose land was it originally, Israel or Palestine?
By more than 1,000 years, “Israel” predates “Palestine.” The land then became home primarily to an Arab population, again for more than a millennium. Both Jews and Arabs thus have a legitimate claim to the land. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict has seen myriad wrongs and brutalities on both sides.
Why did the British give Palestine land to Israel?
In an effort to win the support of Jewish communities in both Allied countries like the United States, and enemy countries like Austria Hungary, the UK foreign secretary signed the Balfour Declaration. Vowing to set up a national home for the Jewish people in Palestine.
Who occupied Palestine first?
In early times, Palestine was inhabited by Semitic peoples, the earliest being the Canaanites. According to tradition, Abraham, the common ancestor of the Jews and the Arabs, came from Ur to Canaan.
Are there any Jews living in the West Bank?
The Israeli Central Bureau of Statistics reports an estimated 465,400 Jewish Israelis reside in Israeli settlements in the West Bank in 2021. Israeli statistics do not count settlements in East Jerusalem as part of the West Bank.
Why did Israel want to take over Palestine in 1948?
The goal of the Arabs was initially to block the Partition Resolution and to prevent the establishment of the Jewish state. The Jews, on the other hand, hoped to gain control over the territory allotted to them under the Partition Plan.
Was Palestine ever a legal country?
The Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) declared the establishment of the State of Palestine on November 15, 1988. As of September 2025, the State of Palestine is recognized as a sovereign state by 157 of the 193 member states of the United Nations, or just over 80% of all UN members.
Can Israeli Arabs live in settlements?
There are 33 settlements with registered Arab residents. Ariel has the largest Arab population out of the settlements, with 573 Arab residents (mostly Ariel University students.) Several others, including Maale Adumim, Kfar Etzion, and Giv'at Ze'ev, have a few dozen (Shaul Arieli, Deceptive Appearances, 99).
Is Israel illegal in the UN resolution?
Resolution 2334 concerns such settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem. The Fourth Geneva Convention makes it illegal for nations to move populations and establish settlements in territories acquired in a war, and an overwhelming number of countries consider the Israeli settlements to be illegal on that basis.
Why is boycotting Israel illegal?
Discrimination argument. Proponents argue that boycotts of Israel are a form of discrimination because they target a particular group (Israelis) with the intent of inflicting economic harm on them.
What right does Israel have to its land?
It is for this reason that Israel, which inherited the sovereign rights of the Jewish people over Palestine, has the legal right to keep all the lands it liberated in the Six Day War that were either included in the Jewish National Home during the time of the Mandate or formed integral parts of the Land of Israel that ...
What UN resolutions has Israel violated?
The relentless Israeli colonisation of the West Bank violates numerous UNSC resolutions, including Resolution 242 (1967), which “[emphasises] the inadmissibility of the acquisition of territory by war”, language which, by and large, is repeated in numerous further resolutions, such as 252 (1968); 267 (1969); 271 (1969 ...
Can Jews be Palestinians?
The term "Jewish Palestinians" can also refer to Palestinian Arab families with Jewish ancestry. Throughout the years several reports documenting traditions of Jewish descent, as well as customs associated with Judaism, were recorded in what is today the West Bank.
Who owns West Bank in Israel?
The mid-1990s Oslo Accords split the West Bank into three regional levels of Palestinian sovereignty, via the Palestinian National Authority (PNA): Area A (PNA), Area B (PNA and Israel), and Area C (Israel, comprising 60% of the West Bank).
How are Christians treated in Gaza?
Some sources have described Christians in the Gaza Strip as effectively second-class citizens who face discrimination and harassment from Hamas.
Who did Gaza originally belong to before Israel?
Before Israel, Gaza was under British Mandate rule (until 1948), then came under Egyptian military administration from 1948 to 1967, interrupted briefly by Israel in 1956. Israel occupied Gaza after the 1967 Six-Day War, establishing military rule until 1994, after which the Palestinian Authority took control before Hamas assumed de facto rule in 2007.
Why do Israelis think Palestine belongs to them?
Israelis believe Palestine (the Land of Israel/Canaan) is theirs due to deep religious ties (God's promise to Abraham), a continuous 3,000-year-old Jewish presence and sovereignty in ancient times (Kingdoms of Israel/Judah), the Zionist movement's goal of a Jewish national home, and international legal recognition via the Balfour Declaration and League of Nations Mandate, all reinforcing a sense of historical and divine right to self-determination in the land.
Was Jesus born in Israel or Palestine?
This country received the name of Palestine, from the Philistines, who dwelt on the sea coast: it was called Judea, from Judah: and is termed the Holy Land, being the country where Jesus Christ was born, preached his holy doctrines, confirmed them by miracles, and laid down his life for mankind.
Who decided to give the Jews Israel?
In 1917, Britain issued the “Balfour Declaration,” which declared its intent to establish a Jewish homeland in Palestine. Although protested by the Arab states, the Balfour Declaration was included in the British mandate over Palestine, which was authorized by the League of Nations in 1922.
Why didn't Palestine become a country in 1948?
The British, who held a colonial mandate for Palestine until May 1948, opposed both the creation of a Jewish state and an Arab state in Palestine as well as unlimited immigration of Jewish refugees to the region.
What was Israel called before 1948?
Before 1948, the territory that became Israel was officially known as Mandatory Palestine, under British rule, though historically it was part of the Ottoman Empire and referred to as Eretz Yisrael (Land of Israel) by Jews and Filastin (Palestine) in Arabic. No single independent country named Israel existed, but the region was known by various names under different rulers, including the Roman-era Syria Palaestina and various Ottoman districts.