Why do companies place arbitration clauses in their employment contracts?

Asked by: Jonathan Senger  |  Last update: November 18, 2023
Score: 4.1/5 (39 votes)

Arbitration Clauses and How They Are Used
Arbitration clauses in employment agreements give employers relief from costly lawsuits and also place restrictions on the discovery process leading up to the arbitration hearing.

Is an arbitration agreement good for an employee?

Arbitrations are less formal than court trials, and this informality can make the process easier for all involved, especially employees who are not used to litigation. Also, cases in arbitration are heard and decided much more quickly than court cases, which can take several years from start to finish.

Why do companies have arbitration clauses?

Why Do Companies Use Arbitration Clauses? More companies include “arbitration clauses” in their customer user contracts and agreements as a way to quickly and calmly settle conflicts. Arbitration clauses permit a business to bypass the formal court system, which many companies feel is more costly and time-consuming.

Why do many employers include binding arbitration clauses in employment contracts?

For employers, arbitration is usually preferable, because it is less expensive than having the conflict go to court. Many employers include an arbitration clause in their Employment Agreements or as a separate Arbitration Agreement.

Is it ethical for employers to include arbitration clauses in employment contracts?

The use of unilaterally imposed mandatory arbitration clauses in employment contracts as a condition of employment harms both the individual employee and the public interest in eradicating civil rights violations.

OK at Work: Arbitration Clauses in Employment Agreements

24 related questions found

Why do employers favor arbitration?

Employers favor arbitration over court action because the arbitration process is more cost-effective and less time-consuming. While arbitration is a formal process, the rules and procedures are less onerous than those of a court of law.

Do employers win in arbitration?

Employers are far more likely to win when they have arbitrated a case before, according to research by professor Lisa B. Bingham of Indiana University. When an employer is in arbitration for the first time, the employee wins 70% of the time.

Should I opt out of my company's arbitration agreement?

Because arbitration prevents your claims taken seriously, there's no upside to remaining in a mandatory arbitration agreement. Even if you opt out, you can still choose arbitration to settle a dispute, so there's no downside to opting out.

Should you agree to arbitration?

Because of limited discovery, lack of a jury, and limited appeal rights, arbitration outcomes are riskier and more final than court litigation. It is hard to see why arbitration would be fairer than court litigation. Arbitration is litigation, just not in court. Arbitration might be the right choice for some cases.

Does arbitration favor employers or employees?

Historically, if an employee or a job applicant signs an arbitration agreement, that person essentially agrees to let an out-of-court arbitrator, rather than a court of law, decide on a wage case or a sexual harassment case. Typically, the arbitration process favors employers, not employees.

What are the disadvantages of arbitration?

Disadvantages of Arbitration
  • No Appeals: The arbitration decision is final. ...
  • Cost: While arbitration is generally a more cost-efficient legal settlement option, it might not make sense in cases when minimal money is involved.

What voids an arbitration clause?

The issue or dispute is not covered by a valid arbitration agreement, such as when there is an issue the parties did not agree to arbitrate; The arbitration was tainted by fraud; and/or. Misconduct on the part of the arbitrator that affected their decision.

Can I sue if I signed an arbitration agreement?

In some instances, you may be able to sue if you signed a valid arbitration agreement. While courts generally favor arbitration agreements, they will allow you to file a lawsuit if you didn't understand your rights or your claims fall outside of the scope of the arbitration provision.

What are the disadvantages of arbitration in employment law?

The Cons
  • It's easier for unrepresented parties to bring weak claims in arbitration. ...
  • Forum and arbitrator costs are higher and, in California and many other jurisdictions, the employer bears the vast majority of those costs.

Are workers jeopardized by arbitration agreements?

Yes. For a variety of reasons, forced arbitration is generally bad for employees. Forced arbitration deprives you of your right to access the public court system.

Are employment arbitration clauses enforceable?

Outside the sexual harassment context, workplace arbitration agreements remain enforceable under federal law.

What happens if you break an arbitration agreement?

If one party repeatedly failed to cooperate with the arbitration, the other would be required to file a potentially unending cycle of motions seeking court orders directing such cooperation.

Can an employer fire you for not signing an arbitration agreement?

Under California law, as well as the law of every other state, an employer can refuse to hire you (or can terminate you) if you refuse to agree to arbitrate all of your employment disputes.

Is arbitration risky?

You should be careful about signing any arbitration agreement, particularly if the provision does not state that the arbitrator must award based on the law, and failure to do so is grounds to vacate the award.

What is an arbitration agreement for employment?

An employment arbitration agreement is a contract between an employer and an employee, sometimes signed prior to employment and in some instances after employment has begun, in which both parties agree to submit any employment-related disputes to arbitration, rather than to the traditional court process.

Can I decline arbitration?

While you technically have the choice not to sign an arbitration agreement that appears to be skewed more to your employer's benefit, the employer can simply rescind its offer of employment if you refuse to sign.

Do arbitration clauses survive termination?

An arbitration clause in a contract is generally regarded as an autonomous agreement that may survive the termination of the contract that contains it.

Who pays for employment arbitration?

The California Supreme Court established several conditions to enforce a California employment arbitration agreement. One of these conditions was that if an employer includes an arbitration agreement in their employment contract, they are responsible for paying arbitration fees.

How does arbitration benefit employees?

Arbitration is often faster than litigation. Employees may not realize that litigation often takes years. Most experts consider arbitration at least somewhat faster. Arbitration is more likely to provide an employee a chance to be heard.

Who usually wins arbitration?

The research results demonstrate that in the forced choice scenario of final offer arbitration, neutrals are typically more likely to select the union's offer than the employer's offer, with employers winning about 40% of the cases submitted to arbitration.