Why should you never take a plea bargain?

Asked by: Dewayne Yost MD  |  Last update: March 12, 2025
Score: 4.9/5 (32 votes)

Critics argue that plea bargains can result in innocent people pleading guilty to avoid the risk of a harsher sentence at trial. There are also concerns about the consistency and fairness of plea deals, as well as the potential for prosecutorial overreach.

What are the negatives of plea bargaining?

Despite its benefits, plea bargaining is not without its critics. One of the most significant concerns is the potential for coercion. Defendants, especially those without adequate legal representation, may feel pressured to accept a plea deal for fear of facing harsher penalties if they go to trial.

Why should you never plead guilty?

By maintaining a not guilty plea, you ensure that your right to a fair trial is preserved, and the burden of proof remains squarely on the prosecution. Additionally, pleading not guilty allows your defense attorney the necessary time and opportunity to build a robust defense.

Who benefits the most from a plea bargain?

Prosecutors benefit from plea bargains because the deals allow them to improve their conviction rates. Some prosecutors also use plea bargains as a way to encourage defendants to testify against codefendants or other accused criminals.

Why might someone who is not guilty take a plea bargain?

Sometimes a defendant may want to take a plea bargain to end a case quickly so that they can protect loved ones or friends who might also be investigated or charged based on the same events.

Plea Bargain Mistakes: When NOT to Plea Bargain. Don't get yourself convicted!

22 related questions found

Is it better to plead guilty or go to trial?

Potential for Reduced Penalties: Often, prosecutors will offer a reduced sentence if you plead guilty, especially in exchange for cooperating with their case or taking responsibility for your actions. If you are facing serious charges, a plea deal might be more appealing than risking a lengthy sentence at trial.

Do innocent people take plea deals?

On the federal level, it is estimated that between two and eight percent of convicted defendants plead guilty to crimes for which they are factually innocent.

Is it better to accept a plea bargain?

When the evidence against you strongly supports your guilt, it may be advantageous to accept a plea bargain; however, when the evidence is weak or non-existent, accepting a plea agreement will leave you facing criminal penalties you may have otherwise not have faced had you gone to trial and won.

Which state actually banned plea bargaining?

ALASKA BANS PLEA BARGAINING. DATA ON COURT OPERATIONS IN ALASKA'S THREE LARGEST CITIES WERE COLLECTED FOR 1 YEAR PRIOR TO AND 1 YEAR FOLLOWING THE STATE'S PROHIBITION OF PLEA BARGAINING IN 1975.

Why do judges like plea bargaining?

Plea bargains can reduce court backlogs, ease financial strains on prosecutor's offices, and free up jail and prison space. Plea bargains hold many advantages for actors in the criminal legal system, not just defendants. Prosecutors and judges stand to gain as well.

Is it worth pleading not guilty?

We strongly advise that you plead "NOT guilty" because you may leave the courtroom in handcuffs. It happens all the time. Remember, most of our clients never go to jail. Some people worry that if they plead “not guilty,” when they feel they are really guilty, that it could hurt them later.

Does pleading guilty reduce your sentence?

You may be able to enter into a favorable plea agreement with the prosecutor if you agree to plead guilty. They may drop the charges to a less serious offense or agree to reduce your sentence. This can be extremely beneficial, especially if you face a jail or prison sentence.

Does pleading not guilty increase your sentence?

Not Guilty

You can later decide to change your plea to guilty or no contest if you wish. If you plead not guilty you will have a pretrial conference to try to settle your case. There is no penalty for pleading not guilty. Your sentence will not be more severe or less severe based merely on how you plead.

How often does a judge reject a plea deal?

How Common Is It for Judges to Reject Plea Deals? The frequency of judges rejecting plea deals may vary depending on jurisdiction and individual cases. However, judges do exercise their authority to reject plea deals when they determine that they are not appropriate or just. It is a rare instance, but it does happen.

Does taking a plea deal mean you are convicted?

When you accept a plea bargain in California, you are pleading guilty to a charge. It may be a lesser charge, but you are pleading guilty, nonetheless. This results in a conviction, and a conviction can end up on your criminal record.

Will prosecutors take a weak case to trial?

Prosecutors are very selective about the charges they file, therefore, and they simply will not pursue a case that lacks sufficient evidence.

What is the biggest problem with plea bargains?

Uncertainty and Plea Bargaining. The major, distinct problem caused by plea bargaining that Professor Bellin identifies is uncertainty—namely, the inability of a defendant to assess whether the plea agreement being offered is better or worse than the likely outcome at trial.

Is plea bargaining fair?

bargaining is known to cause discrepancies in sentencing outcomes. a plea are more likely to receive harsher sentences. seriousness of the current offense and prior record, are important factors in determining whether a charge will be reduced and by how much.

Why should we ban plea bargaining?

Plea bargaining should be abolished because it encourages crime and demoralizes both victims and society. Abolishing it will restore respect for the criminal justice system, which now lets people think that they should get away with crime because they can.

What is one disadvantage of plea bargain?

One of the disadvantages of plea bargaining is that it opens the possibility for innocent people to plead guilty to an inaccurate charge. They may see a plea deal as the safer path to avoid the risk of a trial. Some defendants enter a plea of "no contest" to accept a plea bargain without admitting guilt.

Why would a prosecutor not offer a plea bargain?

Prosecutors usually check with victims about plea deals. If a victim is against it and the case is strong a prosecutor may just choose to go to trial. Sometimes they have office policies especially on certain types of cases against deals.

What happens if you turn down a plea bargain?

When considering a plea deal, you usually have a set time to decide. This is often a few months from when the offer is made. If you don't accept by then, the prosecutor might extend the same offer or propose a new one, which might not be as good.

Should you ever plead guilty?

The best time to plead guilty is when your attorney has negotiated a plea bargain. This is a deal made with the prosecution that drops some of the criminal charges against you in exchange for you pleading guilty to a lesser charge.

What happens to those who plead guilty?

Pleading guilty

If you plead guilty you will get a reduction in your sentence. To qualify for the maximum level of reduction (one third), a defendant must plead at the first court hearing. Defendants who plead later will serve longer sentences than those who accept their guilt and plead at this early stage.

Can a judge refuse to accept a guilty plea?

They can accept the plea agreement as it is, or they can reject it outright. If a judge rejects a plea agreement, they usually must state a justification on the record.